This is a essay that aims to be a correction to what Paul Graham wrote:
Email was not designed to be used the way we use it now. Email is not a messaging protocol. It's a todo list. Or rather, my inbox is a todo list, and email is the way things get onto it. But it is a disastrously bad todo list.
I'm open to different types of solutions to this problem, but I suspect that tweaking the inbox is not enough, and that email has to be replaced with a new protocol. This new protocol should be a todo list protocol, not a messaging protocol, although there is a degenerate case where what someone wants you to do is: read the following text.
While it seemed to have made a little sense at first, I eventually realised that there are other resources whose functionality I use as a to-do list aside from email. For example:
My browser's bookmarks’ menu where I bookmark links to deal with.
My home directory and other directories on my file system where I put non-permanent files.
Non-committed files in version control repositories.
Bug trackers / issue trackers.
Actual to-do lists I keep and manage.
However, there are other aspects for their use aside from serving as a to-do list, and they are all different from one another.
As a result, while trying to create an alternative to E-mail is commendable, I suspect that trying to replace E-mail with a to-do-list-like protocol will not prove to be popular, because like those - E-mail is not exclusively a to-do list.
Copyright by Shlomi Fish, 2017.
You can reuse this entry under the Creative Commons Attribution-Non commercial 4.0 Unported licence, or at your option any later version of it. See the instructions on how to comply with it.